Sunny Days in Heaven
Spiritual/Political/Philosophical Blog on the Nature of Truth and Falsehood and Heaven


Thursday, May 16, 2002  

It will never change while we live in this world

I got the following from Andrew Sullivan:

An effective piece in the English Catholic newspaper, the Tablet, grapples with the idea that dysfunctional or disordered sexuality is the root of the current crisis in the Church. Harvard Jesuit James F. Keenan doesn't deny the sexual dimension, but he sees it as secondary to a deeper issue:

The molestation and raping of children are not primarily sexual acts; they are violent acts of power. By these actions children are harmed, sometimes destroyed. These actions are about power. In fact, most of the scandalous actions of which we read are about power.
When the bishops moved these priests around and assigned them to new parishes and let them have access again to children, these were not sexual acts, but acts of power.
When the bishops and pastors denounced the parents and relatives who charged that priests had abused their children, these denunciations were acts, not of sex, but of power. When the cardinals tried to blame the media for unleashing a frenzy, these were not charges of sex, but of power...
We in the priesthood, from seminarians to the Pope himself, need to learn more about power, about sharing power and about accountability in the exercise of power. Certainly, we need to have a visitation of our seminaries – and of our rectories and our chanceries – conducted not by the Vatican but by competent lay people and priests. The aim should be to see whether we are learning about the extent of our power, of the uses of that power, and of our accountability to God and to the People of God. In the light of those lessons, assuredly, we would see the need to recognise the vocations of others.


Recognizing the vocations of others? Does he mean women priests? Either way, it won't help. Remember Paul at Corinth? A fight over power and authority. Paul barely won. Remember Antioch? Paul tells Peter off (so he says!) but Peter prevails.

Ever wonder why Jesus refused the Devil's offer of absolute power over the world? He knew it was a joke. Power is an addiction, and so the son of man chose to be powerless and free. Do you really think such a man of insight, wisdom, and hatred of power would pick a successor and appoint people to positions of greatness over others - as if that would solve everything? You'd have to have rocks in your head and not just in your name if you believed "Jesus picked me to lead our people."

Look at the whole history of leadership. Consider all the bosses you ever had, and count the number of truly, good folks who were great at it. Find many? Not many. Face it, people - we're stinkers. It is hopeless that we shall ever be well led in this fallen world. But to end on a positive note, there's plenty of grace in living and in prayer to make life worthwhile most of the time. Ya gotta love God and that mercy thang. Count on Providence every time.

posted by Mark Butterworth | 1:08 AM |

links
archives